Church Leadership

St. Peter's Pastor, Worship leader & Staff

Pastor Randy Stull

LEAD Pastor

I grew up in Port Washington Ohio. I married the love of my life Rhonda in 1977 and we had been together for more than 46 years until she went to be with the Lord in 2023.

Rhonda and I have three children. Aaron and his wife Danielle have blessed us with two grandsons. Ryan and his wife Evan have blessed us with two granddaughters. Lastly, our daughter Miranda and Husband Jentik blessing us with their boy Eilo who are also St. Peter's missionaries currently in the United States until their next mission.

I gave my life to Christ at age 17 and have been doing my best to serve him since. I felt a strong call to the ministry by the Holy Spirit and have been in the ministry for nearly 30 years.

I am an Ordained minister and have a background in church planting.          
 Being bi-vocational while serving the body of Christ has been God's plan for me throughout my ministry. I believe that the Bible is God's words to mankind and reveals his great love for Each of us. My passion is to bring as many as possible to be followers of Jesus and be mature in Christ.

If you have any questions regarding God or St. Peter's Church of Oldtown Valley, you can contact me anytime.  (330)407-0191

Rick Keffer

Worship Lead & president

I have been a member of St. Peter's my entire life. I am a simple family man with a love for God and a love for music for over 50 years. I enjoy learning new praise songs, while still playing traditional hymns.

Our goal at St. Peter's is to create an experience that all age groups can worship and give praise together.

If you'd like to join St. Peter's praise team with any of your instrumental or vocal God given talents you can reach me at (330) 340-9060

Sarah Keffer

Church Secretary

I grew up in New Philadelphia, married my kindergarten crush Sam and have 3 beautiful children, Andrew, Madilynn & George.  I first came to Christ growing up in an AWESOME "Mega church" in Canton Ohio where even though there were people by the hundreds you knew them all by name.  This I believe prepared me for the position of St. Peter's secretary today. I'm learning it doesn't matter the size of the church it's about the family of God that shows up every day for God all seeking a closer relationship to Him.  My testimony is that I have the coolest job in the world because I get to see God's glory through His people every single day.

If you are looking to update any information or have any questions you can contact me anytime at (330) 407-2835.

Suzanne Heter

Events Coordinator

Grew up in Oldtown Valley and attended church since my youth.  I love my little church and will be found in the back row most Sundays.  

If you're looking to utilize St. Peter's Church of Oldtown Valley for your event, please contact me at 330-340-7369.  

Natalie & Al Cline

Ladies of light Secretary - Natalie

Both retired nurses who now own their very own Bed & Breakfast and Tea Room called Garver House Bed and Breakfast located in Strasburg. Al grew up on a farm in Bolivar and Natalie grew up on a farm in New Jersey.  Now being married for 39 Years since October.  They have four grown children, Joe, John, Justin and Natalie.  The boys reside out of state while Natalie lives in Parma, Ohio. Al enjoys gardening, working outside and taking walks.  Natalie likes to bake, quilt and work on craft projects.  Both members of St. Peter’s since 2021 and enjoying all the church has to offer.  They’ve helped in various functions including Feast & Fellowship, greeters and most recently Natalie has become the secretary for the women's group "Ladies of Light" here at St. Peter's.  You will find these two sitting in church on Sunday's and can find Natalie at the women's group monthly meetings serving up some delicious homemade pastries!

If you'd like more information on the women's group contact Natalie @ (330)354-6268